By KENNEDY BUHERE
“The purpose of higher education is to teach young people to think, to think straight, if possible; but to always think for themselves.”
Robert Hutchins
Kenyan universities are poised for far-reaching reforms following the development of a draft Competency-Based Framework for University Education (CBFUE) by the Commission for University Education (CUE), which is expected to be reviewed and endorsed by the leadership of Kenyan universities.
Media reports indicate that the Commission has prepared the draft framework which, if adopted, is expected to align university education with the Competency-Based Education (CBE) framework, the blueprint for education reforms whose implementation began in 2019.
The draft proposes changes to what students are taught, how lecturers teach, how students are assessed and the competencies they are expected to demonstrate.
“What we have been doing has been content-oriented. We sit students somewhere, give them an examination where they write down the content we’ve given them and then we mark it. But now we are saying that having theory is not enough. We need to see whether they can apply the knowledge they have,” the media quoted CUE Chief Executive Officer Dr Mike Kuria as saying.
The proposed changes will require smaller classes, additional teaching staff, investment in ICT and infrastructure, curriculum reviews to eliminate unnecessary repetition, and revised teaching and assessment methods focused on demonstrating competence. They could also involve industry players in assessing students.
The planned reforms are admirable. The four-year university education and training experience is not a picnic. Universities admit the crème de la crème of students, the very best of the best in demonstrated intellectual ability and other aptitudes.
In an October 2, 2006 speech titled The Well-Educated Undergraduate, former Cambridge University Vice-Chancellor Professor Alison Richard observed: “Cambridge is clear in its aspiration for undergraduates to be educated up to and beyond the frontiers of knowledge. Their learning focuses not only on what is already known but on scholarship and discovery, not only on acquiring knowledge but on developing their minds to be critical, analytic and inquiring.”
Kenyan universities must, without equivocation, have similar aspirations for the students who enter their gates.
Needless to say, the purpose of university education is to develop critical thinkers and nurture students into responsible and ethical citizens, in addition to fulfilling other obligations, such as preparing them for the job market.
It matters little what kind of education students received at the lower levels of learning, whether basic education was knowledge-based or skills-based. What matters is whether they are adequately prepared for university education and have attained the academic benchmarks expected of secondary school graduates before admission.
Higher education has pedagogical traditions that have undergone centuries of reflection, rethinking and reform. Teaching in top-notch universities now goes beyond the mastery of academic content. It focuses on developing students’ capacity for independent and critical thinking. This is hardly a new concept.
Universities have long employed distinctive pedagogical approaches to teaching undergraduates. These include tutorials, seminars, lectures, workshops and research, among other methods.
The tutorial method of teaching has deep historical roots. It is associated with Professor Benjamin Jowett, the classicist and Master of Balliol College, Oxford, who later became Vice-Chancellor of the university.
“It is through the tutorial system that students develop powers of independent and critical thought, analytical and problem-solving abilities, and skills in both written and oral communication and argument,” Oxford University’s website states.
This is a method of teaching that the University of Nairobi had perfected and which yours truly enjoyed in the mid-1980s. My tutorial fellows in Literature and Government were Professor Odera Outa and Professor Peter Wanyande, respectively.
We attended lectures in large classes but subsequently explored the same concepts and areas of learning in smaller tutorial groups of fewer than 10 students. Issues were discussed, questions raised and answers exchanged in lively, back-and-forth engagements under the guidance of the tutorial fellow.
What am I saying? I am saying that undergraduate students must be encouraged to study deeply and engage with their respective disciplines. Disciplinary knowledge is already available and constantly evolving. It is the depth and breadth of this knowledge, when properly structured and taught, that cultivates and expands the intellectual and thinking capacities of students.
Content or the programme of study alone is not enough.
In his January 31, 2010 annual lecture of the Higher Education Policy Institute at the Royal Society in London, titled The Rise of Asia’s Universities, former Yale University President Richard C. Levin observed that world-class universities “… excel in the advancement of human knowledge of nature and culture; they provide the finest training to the next generation of scholars; and they provide outstanding undergraduate and professional education for those who will emerge as leaders in all walks of life.”
Universities have long been entrusted with the responsibility of enabling students to develop and sharpen the innate intellectual capacities they demonstrated when they qualified for university education.
The prodding they are receiving from CUE through the proposed Competency-Based Framework for University Education should simply serve as a reminder that professors have an even greater responsibility to cultivate the cognitive abilities of their students to the fullest extent possible.
Universities must enable students to acquire the accumulated body of knowledge and skills in their respective academic and professional disciplines. Beyond that, students should master this knowledge sufficiently to apply it when called upon to understand, analyse and manage the problems and situations they will encounter in the future, both in their personal lives and in their institutional or public responsibilities.
There are no two ways about it.
Suffice it to say that CBE did not originate the intellectual and thinking abilities that policymakers now want students to acquire. Nor are these competencies peculiar to the demands of the 21st century. Independent thinking, problem-solving and the other capabilities that policymakers around the world now emphasise have been central to the very purpose for which education was established.
Exceptional men and women in politics, science, business, religion and academia in earlier generations possessed the powerful thinking and analytical abilities that we now associate with university-educated and trained people. A significant number of them did not even have university education. Yet their intellectual development was grounded in the excellent foundations of education and schooling available in their time.
Our universities must rise to the occasion and serve the country by providing students with quality university education.
Some of the most transformative university presidents in the United States did not require external prodding to provide their students with the very best education. They took the initiative to reform university curricula whenever they considered them inadequate.
I have in mind former Harvard University presidents Charles William Eliot, Abbott Lawrence Lowell and James B. Conant; Robert Hutchins of the University of Chicago; and Princeton University presidents James McCosh and Woodrow Wilson.
These men brought purposeful leadership to bear on the university communities entrusted to them. They were transformative leaders who understood that the quality and relevance of university education depended, to a considerable extent, on the vision and determination of those at the helm.
The future and continuing relevance of Kenyan universities will ultimately depend on the leadership of individual vice-chancellors, not on blueprints, however important those blueprints might be.
Kennedy Buhere
Communication Specialist
